Story Maui: A Unique Surfer Cafe Experience in Paia, Hawaii
**About Story Maui**
Nestled in the heart of Paia, Hawaii, Story Maui is a charming coffee shop that caters to both locals and visitors with a menu that delights the senses. Known for its friendly ambiance and artistic décor, the café serves a range of thoughtfully crafted beverages like the unique Thin Mint Matcha and rich Bullet Latte. Patrons rave about the delicious, wholesome bites, including customizable salads and tasty bagel sandwiches, all made with local organic ingredients. With accommodating staff and a cozy atmosphere—often graced by a friendly feline—Story Maui stands out as a perfect spot to relax, work, or simply savor delightful flavors.
Photos & Gallery
Popular Menu Items
Thin Mint Matcha Latte
Banana Bread
Eggs and Salad
Breakfast Burrito
Vegan Ramen
Story Maui: Reviews & Ratings
This coffee shop is very cute, and this order is not on the menu. For 8-9$ you can ask for the eggs with a small salad. Delicious and super healthy. They have hot sauce at the counter you can grab if you want to add some extra flavor. I heard that there’s a cat that sometimes roams this cafe. Lots of local art available.
100% recommend this coffee place to anyone on the island! We ordered the Caramel Haupia and Bullet Latte as our drinks. Both were great and I completely agree with my wife’s first impression: “the sugar level on this drink is perfect!” I would say the same for both of the drinks! We also ordered the Bagel Sandwich which was very tasty and absolutely worth the money!
This is such a cute little surfer coffee shop! Prices were reasonable and the staff was so friendly. The girl helping us went above and beyond to accommodate our dietary restrictions. I ordered the thin mint matcha which I thought was so cool and unique, and it was delicious! Also loved their loaves.
Wonderful atmosphere with a little orange friend. The food and drinks were delicious! The seasonal toast was simple but so delicious as well as the danishes. Definitely a place to come back to.
The menu is simple but really offers something for everyone--sweet, savory, healthy, treats, ad they are really accommodating to special requests like "less sweetener" or "please add an egg". I tried the strawberry scone, nut butter toast, smoothie bowl, Thin Mint Matcha Latte, and Bullet Latte. Each phenomenon and so well thought out! They use local organic ingredients. Absolutely perfect environment on a weekday to pull out a laptop or book and spend some time focusing.
Stumbled upon this cute little cafe on the way to Hana. Ordered the cappuccino, nut butter toast and bagel sandwich. Cappuccino was perfectly rich and the right size. Food was exquisite! They also have some cold brews in tribute of their cat. 10/10 would recommend stopping on the way to Hana!
Organic and fresh, this cafe is a gem in the charming, laid back town of Paia. The drip coffee is superb, the breakfast options remarkably delicious (see photo, also had the smoothie bowl, worthwhile!!), and the baked goods are wholesome, sweet treats ("matcha cherry blossom" cookie, wow). Comfortable setting too and kind staff providing quick service.
Great cappuccino! Espresso was dialed and the microfoam was well done. The milk was creamy and not too hot. I really appreciate the barista’s attention to detail. Definitely going back!
Location
-
115 Baldwin Ave, Paia, HI 96779, United States Hotline: +1 808-214-5722
Welcome to the charming world of Story Maui, a delightful coffee shop nestled in the heart of Paia, Hawaii. Located at 115 Baldwin Ave, this vibrant spot offers much more than just a caffeine fix—it’s a culinary story waiting to be savored. With an inviting atmosphere, complete with local art and the occasional feline visitor, Story Maui is a haven for both coffee enthusiasts and casual diners alike.
As you step inside, you're immediately drawn to the warm décor and the friendly staff who are eager to make your experience exceptional. The menu, while simple, is thoughtfully curated to cater to a wide variety of tastes. Whether you’re looking for something healthy, like their Eggs with a Small Salad, or a sweet indulgence—be sure to try the Caramel Haupia—there's something for everyone. Customer Sophia highlights the unique Thin Mint Matcha Latte, a standout for those seeking something innovative yet delicious.
The emphasis on local, organic ingredients shines through in every dish. Reviewers rave about the Bagel Sandwich and the Nut Butter Toast, which both deliver on flavor and satisfaction. And let’s not overlook the Smoothie Bowl and Strawberry Scone, perfect accompaniments for a sunny day in Maui. Each sip and bite seems to encapsulate the spirit of the island itself—fresh, flavorful, and full of life.
Customers like Aydin and Anna show that it’s not just about the food; it's also about the experience. The atmosphere at Story Maui invites you to linger a little longer, whether with a laptop or a good book in hand. And if you're like Cora, you might just grab a splash of hot sauce to kick things up a notch. The options are endless, and the accommodating staff ensure that your dietary needs are met with a smile.
In summary, Story Maui is not just a coffee shop; it's a destination that tells a story through its food and warm hospitality. For anyone exploring the island—whether a local or a visitor—this cozy establishment is a must-visit, promising great coffee, delectable bites, and a slice of Hawaiian culture. Make sure to save some time to soak in the atmosphere and maybe meet their little orange friend. Come create your own story at Story Maui!